- Home
- Intro to Adonaism
- Culture
- Beit Din
- Contact Us
- Discipleship
- Elder's Page
- Ezrach'
- Adonaic Theology
- From the Bible
- Halakha
- Fundamentals
- Maleh filters>
- Legal Procedure
- Middot for Halakha
- Agriculture
- Animals
- Blasphemy
- Bribery
- Commerce
- Contracts>
- Crimes against humans
- Crimes against God
- Death
- Diet
- Domestic Relations
- Duties to Fellow Man
- Environment
- Estate
- Ethics, general
- Finances, religious
- Halakha, the public nature of
- Idolatry
- Interest and loans
- Justice, the role of in Halakha
- Lawsuits
- Military service
- Nazirite vow
- Occult
- Political leadership
- Sexuality
- Slaves
- Social security and welfare
- Tattoos
- Tort Laws
- Vows
- Warfare
- Witnesses
- Worship
- Fundamentals
- Hebrew Names of God
- Hebrew/Theological Vocab
- Leadership
- Sermons/Talks
- Siddur - Prayer Book
- Statement of Faith
- War of the Ages
- Farbrengen
- Commentary on Ecclesiastes
- The Normal Christian Life
- Commentary on Hebrews
Military service
There is such a thing as a just war. A just war would be one that the Lord would approve and might be listed as one of the His wars (Numbers 21:14) These might include the defense of the weak, the suppression of evil, or the defense of one's home. Further discussion of the boundaries of a just war will be discussed further below.
1. Age of soldiers: Only those who are 20 years old or more must register for military service. (Numbers 1:2-3; 26:2)
2. Selective draft (Numbers 31:3-7) In this case 1,000 were sent from each tribe.
3. Exemption from service
a. Priests (Numbers 1:49)
b. Certain individuals with mitigating circumstances (Deuteronomy 20:5-7) These exceptions allowed those who went to battle were more likely to be single minded in their focus (Luke 9:62). It also ensured that anyone being precluded (even the cowarJust dly) would be building houses, planting vineyards, and procreating, ensuring the ongoing health of the nation.
(1) Built a new house but not yet dedicated it
(2) Planted a vineyard but not begun to enjoy its fruit
(3) Engaged to a woman but not yet married. The man was to leave his parents, build a house and plant his crops before he could go get his "fiancee" and consummate the marriage. So it would have been a particular hardship to leave a house unfinished, a field untilled and a wife contracted in marriage (thus unavailable to others) to a dead soldier.
c. Fainthearted (Deuteronomy 20:8; Judges 7:3). Why? So that his cowardice would not infect others (Deuteronomy 1:28).
d. A bridegroom is to rejoice with his bride. Do not force a bridegroom to perform military service during the first year of his marriage. (Deuteronomy 20:7; 24:5)
4. Don't allow being in a theater of war to be an excuse for being offensive. (Deuteronomy 23:9)
5. Do not abuse the power given by weapons or authority. (Luke 3:14)
6. Cleanliness in the camp (Numbers 31:19-24; Deuteronomy 23:9-14)
a. Both troops and prisoners are to be quarantined for seven days. They are to purify themselves on the third and seventh day.
b. All clothing and porous gear is to be purified.
c. All non-porous material that can withstand fire is to be run through fire as well as water purification.
d. On the seventh day all clothes are to be washed on more time (see b.)
e. If a man ejaculates during the night he is to be quarantined from dawn till dusk, and wash before reentering the camp. (Deuteronomy 23:10-11)
f. Latrines are to be outside the living area (Deuteronomy 23:12)
g. Each soldier is to have a trench tool. When in the field he is to dig a hole, relieve himself in the hole, and cover it up. (Deuteronomy 23:13-14)
7. Regulations in battle
a. Notice to be given and an offer of peace extended. Those who voluntarily surrender may be put to work. (Deuteronomy 20:10-11)
b. Failure to surrender is to be met by siege and all-out war. However, when victory ensues, only males are to be killed.
c. Cities that are far are to be treated differently than cities that may present an ongoing threat to your people. (Deuteronomy 20:15-18)
d. Trees that offer food are to be spared. Only trees that are only useful as building material or fuel are to be used for siege works, camp fortifications or fires. (Deuteronomy 20:19-20)
e. Treatment of captives to be ethical (Numbers 21:2-3, 35; 31:17-18; Joshua 11:14)
8. Financing war
a. Tribute may be demanded from vassal states (2 Kings 3:4)
b. The taking of spoils is allowed. (Deuteronomy 20:14)
c. However, do not look at war as a source of profit. (Genesis 14:22-24)
War as Justice
Mighty warrior, strap your sword at your side. In your majesty and splendor - in your splendor ride triumphantly in the cause of truth, humility, and justice. May your right hand show your awe-inspiring deeds. Your arrows pierce the hearts of the king's enemies; the peoples fall under you. Your throne, God, is forever and ever; the scepter of Your kingdom is a scepter of justice. – Psalm 45:3-6 HCSB
It always interests me to watch the theological contortions well-meaning Christians go through in order to make the Scriptures fit their pacifistic views. Besides the simple facts of Yahweh describing Himself as a Warrior,[1] as the Lord of Hosts[2], and as being strong and mighty in battle,[3] He repeatedly commands us to be strong and to take courage.[4]
The Bible commands us to be trustworthy,[5] God-fearing,[6] capable[7] “point men” who will risk going into enemy territory in order to safeguard our families.[8]
Over and over again, He has commanded His people to bravely[9] fight[10] for what is right.[11] We should be models fit to be emulated[12] by our children who are largely disgusted with the last generation’s waffling on issues of social and ecological justice.
Modern society has loudly broadcast its philosophy of weakness, tolerance, perversity and cowardice. It wants Christians to be confused about their identity and God’s role in their lives. Somehow, mealy-mouthed confusion has become a hallmark of modern intellectualism just as it had in Jesus’ day.[13]
A doll was found at “ground zero” in Manhattan that once belonged to a little child who was killed on bloody 9/11. Who among us would not try to save that child? What man would not seek to bring the perpetrators of that horrible act to justice?[14]
What man would not want to protect women and children? What if the last generation had not stood up and fought Adolph Hitler? Where would we be? What if over two hundred years ago our forefathers had not gone to war? Where would America be?
Abraham waged war in order to recover his captured nephew’s family. He did not simply accept the injustice. He did not burn his draft card. He did not just allow Lot to sleep in the bed he’d made. He did not simply forgive the enemy and love him while hoping that he would change. Unjust, barbaric acts brought about a righteous indignation that caused him to follow God’s will – which is always justice.[15]
Amalek fought against the Israelites and Israel defended itself.[16] They did the same thing with the Midianites.[17] The only way we can discount the hundreds of examples of tzaddiks going to war is to discount two-thirds of the Bible. Each of us must decide whether we will conform to God’s image or futilely attempt to conform Him to ours – and we know where that leads![18]
[1] Exodus 15:3
[2] Psalm 89:8; Isaiah 3:1; 10:16; Jeremiah 35:17
[3] Psalm 24:8; 89:8
[4] Deuteronomy 31:6-7, 23; Joshua 1:6, 9, 18; 10:25; 1 Chronicles 22:13; 28:20; 2 Chronicles 32:7
[5] Exodus 18:21
[6] Exodus 18:21
[7] Exodus 18:25; 1 Chronicles 26:6
[8] Numbers 13:2; 14:38
[9] 1 Samuel 10:26
[10] Joshua 1:14; 6:2-3, 13
[11] Job 17:8; Psalm 11:7
[12] Philippians 2:29
[13] Matthew 7:28-29; Mark 1:27
[14] Proverbs 24:10-12
[15] Genesis 14
[16] Exodus 17:9-10
[17] Numbers 25
[18] Romans 1:18-22
War as Valuing Life
Then Moses and the Israelites sang this song to the Lord. They said: I will sing to the Lord, for He is highly exalted; He has thrown the horse and its rider into the sea. The Lord is my strength and my song; He has become my salvation. This is my God, and I will praise Him, my father's God, and I will exalt Him. The Lord is a warrior; Yahweh is His name. – Exodus 15:1-3 HCSB
The book of Deuteronomy is filled with laws governing warfare. These laws address the treatment of the enemy, courage in the face of opposition, the duty of officers prior to combat, terms of peace, environmental consciousness in warfare, the care of captured women and children and much more.
It is the tragic nature of warfare to produce collateral damage. Buildings are destroyed. The flow of electricity and clean water is disrupted. Innocent civilians are killed. This has been a fact of combat since the dawn of time.
No one wants it to happen. But compare war to the triage that doctors practice every day. There are times when a leg must be amputated in order to save the body. There are times when combat is required, even though it surely means that innocent lives will be lost, in order to save the lives of many more.
How many million more would have died if we had not fought Adolph Hitler? How many more casualties would we have suffered if there had been a brutal ground attack, going house to house, building by building, tunnel by tunnel in Japan, rather than bombing Hiroshima and Nagasaki?
It is an unfortunate fact that wicked, foolish people often do not listen to anything but the whip. Sometimes, they do not even listen to that![1]
To allow terrorists to have the run of the world community because we lack the moral fortitude to withstand them is no different than allowing a serial rapist to run free in our neighborhood because we want to “understand where he’s coming from.”
The Lord God is clear in His stand that when a person’s blood is shed there must be retaliation.[2] Humanity is intrinsically valuable because it was created in God’s image. It does not matter what is the person’s race or creed. It doesn’t even matter what their sexual orientation is. Their value lies in the fact of Who created them.
That is why God requires a life for a life. A common error held by pacifists is that those who believe in capital punishment or the righteousness of self-defense or just warfare have a low view of human life. It is the exact opposite. We hold to such a high view of the value of every individual that we will fight tooth and nail to make sure that not one more life is lost unnecessarily.
[1] Proverbs 10:13; 17:10; 18:6; 19:29; 20:3; 26:3; 27:22
[2] Genesis 9:6
War Justly Prosecuted
Jacob's Portion is not like these because He is the One who formed all things. [Israel is] the tribe of His inheritance; the Lord of Hosts is His name. You are My battle club, my weapons of war. With you I will smash nations; with you I will bring kingdoms to ruin. – Jeremiah 51:19-20 HCSB
Though God approves of the use of war[1], He still finds it repugnant.[2] He doesn’t want anyone to die. He said He wants everyone to find eternal life[3] and He backed up those words by dying for that desire[4].
Therefore, before entering into any war, we must be sure that it is just. What is a just war? Five criteria must be met before combat may be pursued:
It must be ordered by an appropriate authority.[5] The government of Britain no longer represented or cared for its colonies and they rightly rebelled. That action gave us a (somewhat) representative government and freedom of worship.
Its purpose must be to bring about justice.[6] The U.S recognized both the tragedy of millions losing their lives under the Nazi regime and the potential threat to themselves if they did nothing. The U.S.’ entry into that conflict brought about the creation of the State of Israel.
It must be undertaken with the right intentions.[7] I proudly participated in the First Gulf War as a Marine because Iraq had invaded its neighbor. And though I have spent much valuable time arguing for the doctrine of just war, I do not personally believe the U.S.’ current war in Iraq is just. It is my belief that this particular war is not about justice but oil. Moses taught that we should not follow a crowd in wrongdoing.[8] As a patriotic ex-Marine, I use my rights as a citizen of a free country to use legal means to protest what I view as an unjust war, hoping that my efforts will save the lives of fellow warriors as well as Iraqi citizens.
It must have a reasonable chance of success.[9] If there is any way possible, we should avoid going to war.[10] But if it is determined that war is the best way to save the most lives, then we must be certain that we have sufficient resources to see it through to victory.
It must be proportionate.[11] We may not, as the current president of Iran apparently desires, drop an atom bomb killing millions in response to a verbal insult.
Peace often comes at a cost of many acts of liberation. Jesus died once, but that spiritual battle must be fought every day, for every life, until He returns and establishes peace.
Until then we must continually pursue justice and peace – just like the Angel of the Lord, the Lord of Hosts, the King of Kings and Lord of Lords who will one day rule with a rod of iron – sweet Jesus meek and mild.
[1] 2 Samuel 22:35
[2] 1 Chronicles 22:8-9; Psalm 68:30; 120:6-7; Revelation 13:10
[3] 2 Peter 3:9
[4] John 3:16; Romans 5:8
[5] Matthew 22:21; Romans 13:1-6; Titus 3:1
[6] Psalm 82:1-4; Isaiah 1:16-18; 56:1; 58:6-12; Micah 6:8; James 1:16-18
[7] Matthew 6:1-18; Philippians 2:4
[8] Exodus 23:1
[9] Luke 14:31-32
[10] Romans 12:18
[11] Exodus 21:23-27
War as a New Covenant Concept
Some soldiers also questioned him: "What should we do?" He said to them, "Don't take money from anyone by force or false accusation; be satisfied with your wages." – Luke 3:14 HCSB
Some look on the doctrine of just war as a primitive and barbaric theology, but in this view, they have created a god in their own image.[1] They have demeaned themselves and their fellow man; their theology debases mankind to some kind of cosmic accident unworthy of protection.
They often claim that the basis for the belief in the validity of a just war or of a war-prosecuting God can only be found in the Old Testament – as though immutable God[2] changed His mind during the four hundred year silence between the Testaments!
But isn’t it interesting that John the Baptist didn’t advise the soldiers to quit their jobs?[3] And an officer of the invading, Gentile army found approval for his demonstrated faith.[4] There was no mention of any gentle correction, “Now, you know you need to stop fighting…”
Paul taught that properly elected authority may use force in order to bring about justice. Along with increased responsibility, increased authority must come. [5]
God allows a society to develop a police force to stop evil doers from within its borders. Similarly, society must be allowed to develop a military force to stop evil doers from attacking from outside its borders. It is only common sense - good stewardship - to take the battle to your enemy, fighting in and ruining his territory rather than your own.[6]
Jesus used war as a positive illustration.[7] The Master was passionately zealous[8] for “rightness” and in righteous indignation chose aggressive physical action to bring it about.[9] He also said a king should make sure he had the resources to win a war – not just automatically capitulate.[10]
In the Gospels, Jesus did say to turn the other cheek. However, if you look at the context, you will see that this is always to be done in response to religious persecution.
Further, it is a personal decision that can only be made for oneself. I cannot turn my wife’s cheek. My role as her husband precludes it. If she decides to “turn the cheek” to religious persecution, then I must respect her decision. However, until then, I must fulfill my responsibilities as a husband and father and protect my family.[11]
It is true that Jesus said “Blessed are the peace makers”[12] but notice that peace must be “made.”[13] Every day police officers and DEA agents faithfully prosecute an ongoing war so that we might peacefully enjoy our lives.
Peacefulness is not passivity, for God demanded, “Isn’t the fast I choose to break the chains of wickedness, to untie the ropes of the yoke, to set the oppressed free, and to tear off every yoke?”
Following that particular Mitzvah is going to demand the sacrifice of our comfort. He did not call us to a comfortable, feel-good theology but to the prosecution of justice.
[1] Romans 1:18-22
[2] Numbers 23:19; 1 Samuel 15:29; Psalm 33:11; Isaiah 40:28; Malachi 3:6; Hebrews 6:17-18; James 1:17
[3] Luke 3:14
[4] Acts 10
[5] Romans 13:1-6
[6] Romans 13:1-4
[7] Luke 14:31
[8] John 2:17; Psalm 69:9
[9] Matthew 21:12; John 2:15
[10] Luke 14:31-32
[11] Mathew 5:39; Luke 6:29
[12] Matthew 5:9
[13] Romans 14:19